All of EVP's Madison cafes are great, and this one has a cool antique vibe to it. I agree with the other reviewers, that they close too early, and parking can be difficult, but the coffee is more than worth it.
About me: I've roasted coffee at home for the last 7 years and own two professional espresso machines along with two pro grinders and a lot of other equipment, so it's rare that I find cafes that can pull off better coffee than what I make at home. In fact, I've only ever found one or two that can. EVP is one of them.