After three visits, I'd say that Saddle Mountain is a work in progress.
This place has plenty of potential. Nice atmosphere. Great microbrews. Ample pub menu.
The fish sandwich, burger, and pizza were all pretty good. On my last visit, a friend ordered the spinach, strawberry, and grilled chicken salad. The salad was wet (over dressed), the stawberries were frozen, and they substituted field greens without telling her that they were out of spinach.
The wait staff is friendly and polite, but clearly inexperience. They are not up to speed on the menu and beers, and haven't mastered the skills of efficient table service.
I'd love to see this place succeed. The West Valley needs a variety of good dining. Hopefully the owners will step in and provide enough oversight to make this place a great success. Wishing them well.