I'm afraid I was a bit underwhelmed by Aiello's. I really wanted to like this place which is right in my neighborhood, but alas it was just okay. At least we had a Groupon so it wasn't too bad price wise, if we hadn't I would classify them as being a tad expensive for what you get.
I had the wild mushroom rigatoni and it was fine, nothing special nor memorable. My buddy had chicken parm which was beyond overdone, but the sauce was decent. The deli case has all the meat seemingly just thrown in there very unorganized and difficult to see whats what and how much it costs.