What a great little hidden gem! I was in Cleveland for the weekend and I wanted some Oysters and Beer. The atmosphere was better than I imagined! Just because I wanted some seafood didnt mean that I wanted to sit in an upscale restaurant- Nauti Mermaid was comfortbale, fun, and had a playful ocean themed atmosphere. They had plenty of beers on tap. Everyone I was with enjoyed their experience!... I would give them 5 stars... but the chances of everyone in your group wanting seafood is slim so I would recomend adding more non-seafood choices.