I went back to Gotham craving a bagel, forgetting my past disappointments. I was more disappointed than ever.
The food is just not good. The ham, trying to be fancy, is so disgustingly salty and does not belong on an egg and cheese sandwich. The sausage is also some weird patty and not a normal sausage patty you'd have on a breakfast sandwich.
Gotham says it's a NY style bagel shop but misses the mark when it tries too hard. The bagels are great but your egg sandwiches are almost inedible (my friend and I both picked at ours and didn't finish).
The wait for the food is far too long, it's overpriced and nobody smiles.