We have been to Tarbell's numerous times and it is always an excellent dining experience. Most recently we went for dinner on Valentines Day, 2012.
We were promptly seated then water and bread with EVOO were served moments after we arrived. Our server was very informative, extremely pleasant and non-intrusive. Chef Tarbell came by our table and chatted for a few minutes then each course came out as the previous plate was lifted.
The food is always fresh and delicious. My wife had the beet salad and I started with the potato and celery soup. We both chose the fish of the day which was red snapper flown in from Maine. The bean medley that accompanied the fish was just as good as the entree itself. Chocolate cake with pistachio ice cream polished of a wonderful Valentine's dining experience.
Bravo Chef Tarbell
PS
We love this place so much because it is a place for foodies that is not pretentious. It is a business casual affair and the decor and layout are very appealing. The windows always catch our attention because they remain impecibally clean. You'll SEE what I mean.