I usually don't like write a very poor review but I feel compelled this time because I have never paid so much for such bad food in my entire life.
First of all, our group of 6 was seated at a very small table along the window leaving us with no leg room. That made it an uncomfortable experience to begin with.
I ordered the Seafood Brodetto which comes with a Market Fish, Shellfish, Fennel & Cherry tomatoes ($24). The fish I was served which is what I was most looking forward to was about an inch and a half to 2 inches in diamater. It was by far the driest and most tasteless piece of fish I've ever eaten anywhere in my life (not an exaggeration). The mussels and sauce that they were in were again the blandest mussels I've ever eaten in my life. The meal left me 1. Stunned that a meal could be this bad 2. Hungry
My girlfriend ordered a Gnocchi dish. The gnocchi was deep fried and tasted much more like Tater Tots than any gnocchi we've ever tried. And again, the meat was way overcooked.
I can't remember what the rest of the table ordered but only 1 person was satisfied with their meal (they ordered the Lamb Ragu).
Every person felt completely taken advantage of after the meal (Bills were $100/couple approx. with food and drink). We all also left hungry and wanting another full meal. Luckily Underground Kitchen Cooperative had a taco bar set up at Genna's next door that we happily enjoyed.
However, it wasn't all bad. We did enjoy the decor and our server & bartender who waited on us did a good job.
I have to say that I won't ever go back especially since there are many other more affordable restaurants in town to get a much better meal.
I hope for their sake that it was just a bad night. (I will note that this dinner took place on Thursday, September 29th starting at 7 pm). After telling me experience to so many friends over and over I thought it was time to finally spend a few minutes to get this off my chest.
If you are in that area I would suggest Tornado Room, Graze, Fresco, Nat Spil & Tempest as much better options.