I recently stumbled across this place, and I'm a BIG fan of cheesesteaks. The sandwich had great flavor, but the portion size seemed small. The bun they use is almost hot-dog-bun-size, so the full size cheesesteak almost looks like a footlong hotdog. The meat is proportionate to the bun size, and as I said already, it was tasty.
Overall, it's more like 3.5 stars, but Forefathers is still the best cheesesteak I've had in the East Valley.