I have been going to Tarbell's for years and have never been disappointed. They have an excellent wine list.
The food selection is diverse and uniformly excellent.
Whenever I go to Tarbell's I cannot help but remember the time I ordered an Australian Shiraz. I think the food server got confused when he heard me remark to my companion that the Penfolds Grange was one of my all time favorite wines. By mistake he brought the Grange, which was selling for $450 a bottle. After I told him he brought the wrong bottle, he started to walk back to the wine cellar and dropped the bottle of Grange, which shattered, spilling all that great shiraz over the restaurant's floor.
I hope he did not have to pay for his accident.