Underwhelmed.
I have been here twice since they opened and as someone else here said "meh." I tried the pizza and it was fine, maybe a bit on the salty side. It is not Neapolitan style, the crust is a medium thickness. Another reason I was disappointed was the price, it was around 14$ for a one person pizza and that was a takeout price. The counter guy was very nice though.
The second thing that was disappointing was the gelato. If gelato is in your restaurant's name, you should "do it right." Again it was ok, nothing to write home about and very expensive for what you get. I honestly think the ice cream at Ed's down the street is better.
I appreciate any new business that makes an effort to come to my neighborhood, but Gelato Pizza was a big disappointment.