Went on a date Wednesday for dollar oysters and shrimp cocktails. Hard to beat buck a shuck. The happy hour menu from 5-7 features a solid list of starters and entrees all for 9 bucks or less. There are plenty of tables in the bar area, so if you can't get a spot at the actual bar don't worry, there should be room at a table.
We ordered a draft beer and glass of wine from the happy hour list, as well as truffle fries (skip these unless you have a picky eater, very basic), calamari (yum), 6 oysters (still thinking about them) and 6 cocktail shrimp (good size, cocktail sauce was great).
All together it was less than $40 with tip. I'll be there next Thursday to try $2.50 oysters Rockefeller. The staff here are very nice and my only complaint is that they may have been slightly understaffed. The bartender who waited on us was busting her a** and we enjoyed her service, but she deserved some extra help to handle the rush.