I love The Brown Bag! From the ambience to the food quality, this place is a great local eatery. If you're in Monticello, it is absolutely essential to stop for pie. This place is pie heaven! They also have many other tasty offerings from soups and sandwiches to salads and pasta.
I'd recommend the chicken salad sandwich and a slice of their strawberry rhubarb pie with whipped cream and a cup of milk! Perfection!