OK, first visit here and it wasn't great, but we'll go back and try it again.
I had the Baked Meatballs Molisanti which is three large meatballs with sauce and "pizza cheese" as the menu says. Meatballs were ok, all the cheese had melted off the top and slid together on one side of the meatballs, and there wasn't enough sauce to really taste it. I could have asked for more but they take a while to serve and wasn't in the mood to wait. I'd give that dish one star.
My wife got the Portofino Personal Pie, a 4 piece pizza and she ordered onions and mushrooms on it. The bottom was soggy, the sauce had that metallic taste and overall flavor was worthy of two stars AT BEST.
Yes, we'll go back because 1) This is Broadview Heights, home of...well, almost nothing good casual restaurant-wise 2) Theirs is a HUGE menu and I'm sure we'll find stuff we like--at least I hope so, and 3) It hasn't been open that long and it does sometimes take restaurants a while to put things together. And when we go back I will absolutely review it again. Considering there are plenty of good reviews for this location already I'm truly hopeful future visits will be much better.
We'll see.