Went there two nights Feb 20 and 21 2009 when visiting Montreal. First night it was me and one friend. I ordered a chocolate stout and it was great. Then I ordered a Guiness. The choc stout must have had a good amount of alcohol because I had felt a bit wrecked the next day. And I'm a lightweight.
I liked that you could get name brand beer in addition to their house brewed ones. The atmosphere was good too save for the paintings of people with gas masks on the walls which were oddly interspersed with paintings of trains.
The next night I went back with a bachelor party. I decided to pick up a round of shots we did when we go there. I figured I would get screwed but they had a special, 5 shots for $18.50 which is cheap as far as shots go.
I really liked Brutopia. I would go there again next time I am in Montreal.