CHARMING.
My boyfriend is a Badger so we decided to sneak off to Madison for a nite and stayed at The Edgewater, we're so happy we did!
They're right on the lake and have an awesome deck where you can order drinks galore... I think they also offer food, but who knows. :)
Decor is "classic", so don't go if you're expecting rooms that are super modern... The 2nd sink and vanity station outside the main bathroom was a nice touch... rooms also seemed dark, but with a view of the lake it didn't really matter much to us.
Highly recommended, we're hoping to return for homecoming!