I was really hesitant to go here despite the glowing reviews and top star rating for Madison pizza mainly because after looking at their menu it seems a bit "fancy" for me in regards to some of the toppings I don't even know what they are to be quite honest. I don't consider myself a "gourmet" guy really but I do know good pizza so I figured despite the appearance of this place on here and how their menu read I"d give them a try. Well I"m glad I did because this has got to be the best pizza place here in Madison. I tried the greek salad (side) and the pizza diavola. I decided to add sausage and red onions.
I think it's a little odd they only do one type of pizza size here but hey I'm cool with it because the pizza is so damned tasty. Others have raved about the crust and how fantastic it is and you can add my voice to that list. I think I seriously could just eat this crust by itself with nothing else at all on it. It's just that good. But that's not the only thing that's great here, the sauce is very minimal but just explodes with flavor when it blends down in with the crust. And of course the toppings are all very fresh tasting and also simply are very, very flavorful. The whole thing just pops of taste in each bite.
The greek salad was good as well and a pretty good deal for $5 for the side salad. It was quite large and I feel it's a great value for the money. Of course the pizza isn't too cheap since what you're getting is basically going to feed one person, maybe two if each of you have a salad and aren't big eaters but you're paying for the top quality here for this pizza, not quantity.
So if you're like me and not a real fancy gourmet type guy don't be intimidated or think you're going to get this pizza and think, eww what is this weird stuff. Instead you should give it a try because it's really indescribably good! And if you don't know what some of the toppings are, just use google to find out!