Overall not as bad as some of the previous reviews. But of course I opted for the burger which I custonized to my taste. Not the most difficult item to make.....neither are fries. I did order TRUFFLE fries but my fries had NO truffle flavor in them at all. The bartended swore that she smelled truffles....well I use truffle oil ALL the time and I assured her that these fries had NO truffle in them.....I don't believe she knows what truffle oil is supposed to smell like. Nonetheless she didn't charge me for the truffle fries which was a PLUS!
Nonetheless the fries were good. They were garlic herb. Burger was very good, and they got my CRISPY bacon order correct.....I HATE soggy bacon! Burger was medium well....I ordered medium but it was still good.
Got their house Cabernet which was decent....it was a Mondavi Vendage...or so the Bartender said. Seemed better than a Vendage.....only $5.50 so not a bad deal at all.
Note that I came at 330pm....an off time. So I sat at the bar. Can't say what their normal service is like. Bartender was cool and attentive.
I will try City Tavern again. Good experience with a couple of miscues. But compared to VILLAGE Tavern. ...Village wins every time!