3.5 stars!
Been here only three times, and I've enjoyed myself 2/3 times, I remember it had cheap-ish drinks and had a good selection of cocktails as well. The only reason it gets 4 stars over 3 is because I really enjoy it's basement set up of comfy and cozy seating.
I've not had any food here so I have no clue what that's like. If you do plan on spending the night moving around this area, like Tiffany G says, this place is the clear cut winner to start your night off. And it's so close to the Brunny that it just makes perfect sense to have a drink or two here before heading to the madness that is the Brunny or hop (possibly literally) next door to Futures Bakery where you can sample some yummy cakes or drink more!
But do be warned if you are with a large group, call ahead or get there early as this can get crammed up easily and definitely try to take over the basement!