We used Carpe Diem to cater our wedding, and it they were nothing short of outstanding. Bonnie is amazing to work with - she is unbelievably creative with her cooking, and really helped us to get the exact experience we wanted. Our guests all raved about how great the food was, which was really important to us as foodies.
Every time we've come here as diners, the experience is just as good. The only time it wasn't to the nine's was during restaurant week, when (like most establishments) they are extremely rushed.
Definitely give this place a try, it's 100% worth it.