Went here twice during my stay in Toronto. I had the Llanera beef arepa and my friend had the pulpo arepa and both were absolutely amazing. The steak was perfectly done and the octopus was marinated in a citrusy-sauce. Their herb-maya is fantastic.
If you aren't full after the arepa, try the tres leches cake. You won't regret it!
Thought little pricy but worth a visit and the staff is super nice!