Actually 3.5 stars...4 stars if certain portions just slightly larger.
Great start with a very fresh and well done calamari dish - the surprise ingredient- peppers. It works!
We had Cashew Crusted Tilapia and a Perfect Combination [my combo:Crab Cake - Ahi Tuna]
The tilapia was fresh and tasty. The crab cake was good, but smallish. The first piece of tuna was over cooked, but the waiter quickly replaced it with one that was perfectly seared and was excellent. The tuna portion was also a little on the small side. However $22 for a crab cake and a piece of Ahi tuna is reasonable. Butternut Squash Orzo was a welcome side to the perfect combination.
Maybe my 3 star review is a reaction to the presentation of the food. Crab cake/Tuna/Orzo/Veggies did not 'fill' plate, no garnish...seemed empty. Four parts floating on white porcelain rather than connected and presented as a whole-
Have eaten at many M&S in many cities through business trips and the food is consistently well prepared. No different here on the South Side.