I've had my fair share of visits to this place, I like to sit downstairs at the bar. If you're lookin' for a table, they have seating upstairs and some of the tables have a really nice view of the square. Which is where I've say each time I've came for dinner.
Food quality is good, but nothing that blows my mind. Their cheese curds are pretty darn tasty, so I tend to go for drinks and curds if I'm headed to the Old Fashioned.