Sandwiches were great, dessert cheesecake mediocre. Service was so-so, and it was very noisy inside. Nevertheless for a smoked meat sandwich this is a safe choice.
There is another Reuben's a few units away, it's in the basement. I'm not sure if it is the same owners or not, but that Reubens also has good sandwiches. It's quieter, old school, and less chic as this location.