I have had Cakestar before while walking home one day along Lakeshore and stopping in for one of their cupcakes in their storefront. It was delicious and my 20 month old daughter was also a fan (she had the birthday cupcake).
Just this past weekend however I ordered their sweet tray for a birthday party and we were even more impressed. First, my husband forgot to pick up the tray before closing on Friday but I was lucky that they picked up my voicemail that evening and stayed open a bit longer so that I could run over and grab the tray. Second, the macarons were TO DIE FOR. Blue Macarons with a strawberry flavoured centre. I really didnt think I would like it (not a big strawberry cream fan) but Ive been converted. They were definitely the biggest hit out of all the sweets on the tray. The cake pops were great and the kids loved the cupcakes. I am a huge canoli fan but unfortunately we had to pick the tray up the night before the party and even being in the fridge all night I feel like they lost their crispiness. Certainly not the fault of the store and even with it not being as crispy, the flavour was still amazing. Finally, my mother in law is gluten free and we ordered a separate gluten free chocolate cupcake with chocolate icing. She is a bit hard to please but she agreed it was one of the best cupcakes she has ever had :).
I would order from here again and I will definitely be back for more Macarons. MOUTH WATERING!