Never had a bad meal. Everytime I'm in Madison, I stopped here at least once. The pasta salad is maybe the best thing I've ever eaten (sugary, salty, spicy... tasty). My wife is from Madison, and I had never experienced this place until I'm at my in-laws, great place for a first meeting and for conversation.
Parking can be a little awkward at lunch time but there's plenty of seats inside and little nooks and crannies where you can disappear, or there is a patio. Can't say enough about the food.