After reading all the five-star reviews on Yelp, I decided to give My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria a try. I used to like the restaurant that was located there before, Slices of Sicily, so I was hoping the pizza would be similar or better. The restaurant had been remodeled and looked nice inside, so I initially had some hope the dining experience might be better too.
Unfortunately, My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria turned out to be a disappointment. Things did not get off to a good start when I found out they do not offer slices for dinner. This seems strange given that the word slice is in the name of the restaurant.
I could accept the lack of a slice option if the pizza had been good, but the pizza I ordered with regular sauce lacked taste and was salty. My friend got two varieties of the wings and did not care much for either. The salad I ordered was OK. Given the prices and the lack of taste of the food, I will not be returning, especially with Pizza on 40th up the street as a better alternative.