I would give the food three stars and the experience one star.
The menu was interesting and our food had good flavor....maybe a bit heavy on the salt on the lobster bisque.
The menu includes dishes that you would find at an "upper middle" type restaurant. Starters and salads from $8-12 and entrees from high teens to twenties (didn't ask the price on the specials which included a steak dish which may have been higher)
The problem was the experience. The menu doesn't match the atmosphere or the décor.
I called earlier in the day and reserved a table for 2. When we arrived, a middle aged lady was less than welcoming and acted very "put out" by our arrival for our dinner reservation. She didn't make eye contact, , talked to another employee and told us that they were we could sit over at one of the high top tables. These tables were maybe 2 feet in diameter, and looked more appropriate for having a drink than eating a meal. Our other choice was that she could put us in the "side room".
We were seated at a table in a room that was maybe 10x14 and our 2 seat table was crammed against a wall and the entry door to that room. We received cold blasts or air every time that the front door was opened. The back of the room opened directly into the dish room where we heard loud talking and clanging of dishes throughout our meal. When we mentioned this to our waitress she did holler at the was crew to close the door, but within 5 minutes it was open again and remained open throughout our meal. When the phone rang, there was a loud speaker that I think was right above our table.
Our waitress was friendly, and she did offer to move us back into the other room with the high top. Service was attentive, but not amazing.
The décor is very quirky. I don't mind quirky, but I prefer clean and "tasteful" quirky. This place was neither. The tables were ugly formica and the chairs were the cheap vinyl covered seats like you would find in a diner or Denny's.
Despite our experience, my husband left over a 20% tip saying that it wasn't the waitress' fault and it's Christmas!