Looking at these 2 and 3 star reviews I am shocked. This place hands down has the best pizza in town and if you eat in the service is to die for. I am not familiar with the NYC style pizza aside from my knowledge that the pizza slices are huge, but man o man this was good stuff. The ingredients are fresh and the service was second to none. I also thought it was very reasonably priced. For $25 me and my wife got a 16 inch pizza, a dozen hot wings, and garlic knots and did not finish it all by a long shot. I thought the marinara was delicious and I love extra cheese on pizza.
To put this in context my wife HATES pizza, and will never go near the stuff. She will however eat here. That's how good it is. Don't miss out.