I'm surprised that I had not heard of this place prior to today. Although the menu may be short, everything in it is worth giving a try. We came with a large group so we were able to sample most of it and we were all more than satisfied (I would suggest swapping your side of fries for truffle fries). The servers were very friendly and accommodating. Also, the chairs are extremely comfortable, which may not seem important but they improved my experience. Overall, I would recommend Everly if you're looking for food that is worth its reasonable price.