I really loved this place. We were visiting from Colorado and Papago was suggested by a friend of mine. When we first walked in, I was a bit disappointed by the sort of make-shift interior (though I believe they are doing some sort of construction, so I excused it). However, we grabbed a seat at the bar and were pleasantly surprised by their awesome selection of draft beers--everything from their in-house brews to Dogfish Head to a wide selection of Colorado brews. I originally had heard about their Orange Blossom beer, so I inquired about it to the bartender. She basically said it's their "appeals to the masses" beer and suggested otherwise, which I was ever so thankful for after I tried a sample of the Orange Blossom. Bleh. If you like beer, you probably won't like this. Waaaay too sweet. I was so happy she steered us otherwise.
I ended up with a Coconut Coffee Stout (delish!) and my husband had their Hopago IPA, also delish. We tried a few samples of their other beers on tap and talked beer with the bartender. I am still in awe of their refrigerated beer case--they had more kinds of New Belgium brews than we have in any liquor store right in Fort Collins!
Overall, beers are great and the staff was great with us. I would say 4 instead of 5 stars because we noticed that the staff is a little less friendly with beer rookies, but if we lived in Scottsdale, we would be here at least once a week. Definitely worth checking out!