Most memorable moment: Watching Lebron kick ass in the 2012 NBA finals on the big screens, watching someone get (smirnoff) iced - on his knees and everything, and then debating for the rest of the night whether or not Church Key is actually a renovated church. Thanks to Blair P., I now have my answer.
Second most memorable moment: Receiving a text from my friend saying that she got drunk and "fell out of church key." ?!?!?!?! Just kidding, she actually fell outSIDE of Church Key.
The atmosphere is super laid-back and casual. The few times that I have seen Church Key get even slightly close to rowdy was once before UW let out for the summer, and then once during the NBA finals. The music is good (top40). The crowd is great (caught our neighbors doing the dougie). The booze flows freely. There isn't much more that I look for in a late-night establishment.
Also, you really can't beat the $2 pitchers of beer on a Thursday night. Even a non-beer drinker like me can appreciate that!