I have family who live in Bainbridge, and every time we come to visit them, Dairy Island is a must stop! I love the custard with the crunchy topping; I've yet to find anything like it at any other ice cream shop I've visited around the country. I have also tried a few of their sundaes, and my favorite is the Death by Reese's Cup, which is exactly what it sounds like. It's glorious.
I haven't had any of the actual food, but it always smells so yummy!
When it comes to simple and delicious ice cream, Dairy Island is the place to go!