After three trips to Tornado I've decided on two stars.
Pros: Old school atmosphere, sides included, great lighting, comfortable bar.
Cons: Waitstaff knows nothing about wine (literally), steaks are below average quality for the price, service in general feels more like a pub than somewhere that serves $45 pieces of beef.
Honestly I'll probably pay a few more bucks for a real steak at a place like...well...I guess that's the issue in Madison...Flemings is stupid overpriced and Delmonicos is hit-or-miss.
Overall Tornado is uniquely Madison and has its pluses. But when I'm spending that much money I expect a little better service and quality.