Food: 3
Service: 4
Uniqueness: 3
----------------------------------------------
I've started adding sub ratings to my reviews because I specifically noticed how service can really make an experience better.
I've lived in Madison off and on for 10 years and I just started making Old Chicago one of my regular places. If you're looking for a really unique dining experience, this isn't going to fit the bill. This is a place for a decent slice of pizza with people are amongst the friendliest staff I've ever had the privilege of being served by.
The food is solid but is a bit on the expensive side but the staff are just awesome. You get the feeling that if you became a regular the staff would invite you to join their bowling league.
Go there to catch a game and grab a brew. You won't regret it.