I'm a huge fan of seafood and was super excited to try all the crab boil restaurants popping up in Toronto. Having tried Captain's Boil, I would have to say Boiling Harbour wins, hands down. The flavours are so much more complementary to the accompanying seafood as opposed to the overpowering sodium at Captain's Boil.
Food - Between two hungry people, we usually order 1lb shrimps (Harbour sauce, medium spice), 1lb mussels (Harbour sauce, hot spice), Crab claw poutine (TO DIE FOR!!!!!!) and two steamed rices. We leave happy and pretty full but not to the point of hating yourself and your life decisions :)
Service - Whenever I've been here the service has always been better than average. Things are forgotten here and there but it's not really anything to sweat over. There was one server who made our time there super memorable simply because he was such a comedian.
Really love this place.