This was my 3rd time there, the first 2 times was about average. Today I ordered a burger med well and it, came out med-med rare and it looked as it had been sitting under a heat lamp waiting for other food. The fry's were cold and way over cooked. My wife's fry's were hot but under cooked. Don't expect customer service once you get passed the front counter. The 4.75 star rating that is has should be 2.75 for a burger joint/ sandwich shop. Not my first choice, by far..... The owner is really nice, but it's a little place and way over rated to say the least.......This place, and as for most Restaurant Reviews on yelp are rated way to high......As for NY Flavor.... there wasn't much there.........They made me another burger, I took it to go and got home and it was cooked the same way.. Med- Med Rare..... I like my burgers Med Well............not that hard to do.......