Besides the amazing live music by Jeremy Cornwell, my latest visit to Hearthstone was disappointing. The shrimp pasta I loved so much (see previous review) was replaced by a new version with a heavier sauce and much smaller shrimp. A big departure from the old dish. Nothing special about it and I probably wouldn't order it again. The lobster cocktail was tiny and overpriced.
On the flip side, the grilled octopus was very good. My husband had the lobster roll, which he really enjoyed. Service was also pretty good.
I'm not one to choose quantity over quality, but the value should definitely be there. If you're paying $100 for dinner for two (no alcohol), you should be left feeling satisfied. This wasn't the case for me, unfortunately.