Seeing the other reviews and the fact that this is in my neighborhood I thought I'd finally give it a try. To be honest (and to date myself), this location has always been a pizza place. Way, way back it was called Sammy B's Pizza. Loved it then.
This is a small place, not much seating inside but more outside. Everyone I interacted with was very friendly and explained how it all works. I got a pizza, half salad, order of garlic knots and a cookie - TO GO.
The service was good from everyone except the 2 guys whose job it was to cook the pizza's and get orders out. There is not a lot of room back where they are and they seemed to be constantly in each other's way. This seemed to slow them down too.
I saw my pizza come out first and then sit while one of the guys just kept ignoring it to deal with inside orders. WTF?! It sat and got cold until one of the other worker's told the guy to get the rest of the order going. It took them way too long to get the salad (lettuce, cheese and dressing), and garlic knots together to finish my order. This is my biggest disappointment of my experience.
Price - fair for what you get
Food - pizza was fine. I think I will have to play with getting some other toppings so it tastes a bit better. It wasn't bad pizza, but it also wasn't the best pizza either. Somewhere in the middle. Good for takeout and to satisfy a quick pizza craving. The garlic knots were decent as well. Again somewhere in the middle. I've had better elsewhere. These seemed to be lacking enough garlic flavor, they were more just oily.
I will definitely try this place again and hope for a more satisfying experience with food and service. Fingers are crossed!