Recently moved to Madison, and was pretty disappointed by the amount of Indian restaurants that lacked flavor. Chaat Cafe will indulge all the cravings you may have for "chatpata" food (and for me it's all the time). I love that their papdi chaat has pomegranates in it. My husband inhales their samosa chaat.
Reading the reviews below seems like people's overall disappointment of a new restaurant (not having chai cups etc). But they're new, and figuring it out. And for being new, they have a generous menu with an insane amount of food. They'll figure out what works and what doesn't. I just wish it was closer to where I lived.