We went to Delcomicos for our anniversary and they made it very special. I'll start with the good, the petit filet with wild mushrooms and garlic mashed potatoes- seriously melts in your mouth! Excellent flavors. The waitress recommended a limited time mushroom topper that was more of an earthy flavor, and honestly they were awful. Just not for me, I think they are an acquired taste. I mentioned it to the waitress and they were so nice to take it off. I didn't even ask for it, so I'm great fun for that. We also Tried the scallops which the flavor was there, but were slightly underdone. The only reason for not 5 stars was the scallops and the oysters. The oysters just had no wow factor. For the price, they were just not very good. But we will definitely be back!!