Came here for a buddy's b-day. I was amazingly surprised at how good this place was. Their salad (I had the Caesar) was incredible. Their rotisserie chicken dish was really good as well. Definitely on par with restaurants in NY, and in some cases much better than some overly hyped places in NY (I'm looking at you No. 7!) I've also heard very good things about their burgers.
The food isn't going to blow your socks off with any new unique flavor or flare. They don't have a Picasso working the kitchen but this isn't necessarily a bad thing. It keeps prices reasonable and what they do make, they make it very well. I didn't get to try 30 restaurants in the area but I have to imagine this has to be one of the best ones.
I should also mention that the service and ambiance of the place were also excellent. Great place for a special occasion or a nice night out when you don't want to cook.