I have been to Chesterland Tavern twice, and I want to like it more. The bar is fun (especially the back bar/patio area). The first visit I had the pizza flatbread that was completely burned on the bottom. Try number 2 was made with the wrong toppings. I decided to hold off on try number 3.
My next visit I tried the fish and chips. I love coleslaw, so I made sure I got that on the side. I have never tasted huge chunks of onion in Cole Slaw before, but I have now. And WOW is it terrible. Overpowering everything in the slaw. Not good. Fish was "ok" but nothing special or flavorful about it.
I'll come back - just not to eat.