I'd have to agree with the 4 star average rating.
I've eaten here a few times and have come away content, but not blown away. Everything is done well but not over the top, which may be their intent.
Food wise they do offer a great selection of beef from domestic, domestic kobe, or the way out of my price range imported A5 wagyu. They seem to always push the domestic kobe skirt steak, which is actually really good. Don't bother with the scallops as someone else mentioned. They are small and way overcooked. You are at a steak house.. stick with the steak.
Sides are really good. They offer roasted sunchoke which is something I've never tasted previously, but I do miss the pan roasted sweet corn. Warm frisee salad is always a winner to start with.
Ambiance is nice, kinda dark inside unlike Carne Vino or Joe's.
Oh they do have the BEST rolls. I could eat about 50 of these.
4 Stars!