I would give it three and 1/2 stars if it was possible. I had a visitor from out of town and wanted to show off what some magazine touted as "the best pizza in America". Heritage square is darling and I love the vibe down there. However, we had to wait 2 hrs. for a table. Of course we were steered next door to their little overflow bar to wait for our table. We got drunk and ordered several small plates out of ravenous hunger during our wait..... to the tune of 50 bucks. It's really a brilliant concept Pizzeria Bianco has down there. Send 'em next door forever til they've spent 2x as much as they would have if they'd just gone to the restaurant. When we were finally seated and received our pizzas, they were very good. I have nothing to complain about except they were a bit overpriced. The last city I lived in has a pizza place called Punch. You can order take out from Punch and because the ovens are so hot, the pizzas only take like 3 mins. to cook. You are in and out of there quickly. .....even if you choose to dine in. It's not as fabulous as Pizzeria Bianco, and it has counter service, but their pizza is every bit as good. They have my beloved Buffalo mozzarella and the pies are half the price. So myself and my visitor, having dined at Punch many times previously, were let down by Pizzeria Bianco. Maybe it was just hyped up so much by the press that it would inevitably disappoint me? dunno......but I believe they would do well opening a take out space somewhere in midtown.