I want to give Earl of Sandwich 5 stars. I really want to. It was good, but I didn't think it was orgasmically good. Perhaps all the hype and high expectations made me feel like I would be eating a slice of heaven.
I had The Original 1972 and it was delicious. It was a great sandwich for sure but I couldn't really understand what the hype was all about. My theory: People love it because the rest of the food in Vegas is either way too expensive or if it is affordable, then it probably sucks. As other Yelpers have mentioned it was definitely the most affordable and tasty meal in Vegas.
I was also intrigued by their Earl Grey Lemonade but they ran out of it when I was there.
Would I come back again? For sure. It beats paying $20+ for a crappy Vegas buffet!