Gelato, 5 stars. You have to try the Blueberry Muffin flavor because it is out of this world. Fresh berries and even little cinnamon streusel bits. My mouth is watering just thinking about it. I love that you can order by the ounce instead of in pre-determined small, medium, large sizes. Obviously Mercurio's is known for their pizza and while I find it to be tasty and good, I'm not over the moon about it. I have tried the margherita, margherita with bufala, lasagna and something with prosciutto on my various visits. Despite the overall pizza being 'just okay', I think the crust is fantastic--slightly sweet, fresh and chewy without sitting in a blob in your stomach. I love Mercurio's to pop in to on off times, but don't think it is worth waiting hours for during peak times.