So the food's not bad -- their cheese curds are awesome, which is a big plus in my book! They have so many yummy looking menu options (vegetarian, too!!), it's hard to make any decisions on food! Everything from brats to falafels to peanut stew. You can't beat the beer, of course, but they had none of the seasonal brews listed on the menu. And the location rocks.. the old Fess Hotel off the square (old timers and natives will remember the old landmark). What did not make me happy on my first homecoming to Madtown in at least 6 years.. super cute boyfriend in tow? We were a group of 5 on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving, and the place was not crazy -- yet they sat us downstairs in the basement in the furthest corner next to the loud party-table of lawyers having some kind of award ceremony for themselves. Not cool when I wanted to be able to talk to my family and impress the boyfriend. The table was filthy, which is just gross! The waitress was awkward and slow, though this can be chalked up to a newbie... and the party-table of lawyers, probably. At least we were conveniently next to the bathroom.. right? I was disappointed.