4.5 stars (I've never met a place that I'd give 5 stars to as "the best i've ever had")
Very cool place. I read about this in the newspaper and then heard nothing but great reviews. After a night out with friends we decided (I convinced) that we should check it out for dessert. I heard about the PB&J pasty so I wanted to try.
We showed up at 10pm on a Friday and the seating was ample for our group of 8. The chairs are church pews and the decoration/ambience is really, really well done.
The staff is extremely nice and helpful (and fast). We had a few Banoffee (which although sounds like coffeee, has nothing of the sort in it) and PB&J desserts which were great. Admittedly the PB&J was really, really sweet. But I still ate it all.
I can't wait to come back for their other food for lunch/dinner. I was recommended to try the Royale with Cheese pasty upon return (an homage to Pulp Fiction, of course).
Try this place out! I don't drink, but looked like a great hang-out if you do.