I decided to chance it despite numerous bad reviews, and I can honestly say overall I'm impressed.
The overall pizza is well balanced with the sauce not overpowering the cheese and vice versa; it also taste more fresh than other places around it. The thing that really got me was the crust; this is the lightest, fluffiest crust I've ever had.
The only thing stopping from a perfect rating is the fact that gus pizza has no warmer; meaning your pizza will lose heat really quickly and germs will grow. So make sure you come get your pizza 5-10 mins before pick up time!