I love Humble Pie. I am in walking distance and due to its convenient location, my boyfriend and I often dine there. We've never had an issue with service and have tried, with pleasure, almost everything on the menu.
They have a great happy hour, featuring half priced drinks and food options for $2-$5. The happy hour runs everyday from 3-6, which works out well for our schedules since we usually want a late afternoon snack on Saturday or early dinner on Sunday. (If you don't like kids or crowds, I advise getting there early on Sunday night as it's their Kids Eat Free night and it gets loud and busy.)
We get to-go food a lot. Last week, we abandoned our usual pizza order (Pizza Margherita) for an impressive steak salad. The steak was very lean and prepared to a perfect medium rare. It had really nice flavor, as well. The salad was a mix of romaine and arugula, which paired well with the steak. It was served with an absolutely delicious caper-mustard vinaigrette.
I'll keep updating this as I eat there a lot!